GnomeZome's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[pon3mx animation]

Hola amigo, no hablo mucho español, pero quería decirte que me gusta tu trabajo. Diré más en inglés, pero gracias por hacer esto.

Nice work, i think you show a lot of skill and commitment to your style while working in a very limited tool set, and I hope you have the opportunity to keep pushing your skills.
I look forward to checking our more of your work, as you seem to have a good sense of humor, and sense for simple but effective animation.
Thank you for making this.

PON3mx responds:

dude
you made me happy haha
The truth is if I am very limited in terms of animation tools, all my animations are made in 3ds and also most of my drawings I digitize there because I have nowhere else to do it. thanks for the support!!!! I appreciate it

[FNF - Vs Mom]

Hey, Just wanted to say good work.
I think you really managed to create some compelling dramatic tension witin a short time.
The little details like Bf's sweat, and Mom's cunning grin all work very well, and I like the visual language you used to show the back and forth.
Thank you for making this.

Oswelt responds:

Wow thank you very much, hope you stay to watch my next projects.

[Bones in the Ocean - Forever W.I.P]

Solid!
I like your lip sync work, and the transition from solo to chorus where you had the sailor close his eyes, and had the unearthly sheen rise up his face?, ooooooo smooth work that is really animation efficient.
Thank you for making this.

NandoMations responds:

Oh, dude! Thanks so much for the compliment! Glad you enjoyed it!

[raro raro - sebi bananas]

Hola!
Realmente no entiendo español, pero quería decir que me gustó la música y el video.

A I do not know too much Spanish and I think there was some slang involved, that I would have no context for I decided to vibe along.
I see that you where debating subtitles, but I think your right that the interesting sense of boredom/soft anxiety that people get from using their phones can be a very odd state of mind.
The soft persistent lapping of the music tides was very nice, and maybe instead of subtitles throughout at the very beginning have a message of listen/watch/feel so people focus on that experience.
I like most animation framing of the song that you did in the video, but the part where the pov was warping through space and random images seemed to be coming up was fairly abstract and obtuse, but I got the sense that those figures where the POV's friends or memories?
I also like that you played with keeping things realistic, but also had the general style looking like a filter over real images.
Finally, Lovely guitar work, with a nice acoustic strum.

Thank you for making this.

xdsebaxd responds:

Thanks for the extend feedback, really appreciate.

I doubt if it was okay to uplado it here, because its an animated video for my musical project wich is enterily in spanish. But for your comments it worth it :)

[HOLLOW KNIGHT: BIRTHPLACE]

A place that FEELS wrong, but IS right.
I really like what you captured here, as it reminded me of why I adored the game so much.
Know that each push forward would have a push back, that each dark tragedy would have a greater weight but let me go farther.
I think you did pretty well with the spoiler warnings even if the name itself has some spoiler elements to it, it has been almost 4 years.
Most of great work carving out some much emotion from all that darkness.
Thank you for making this.

RemiRecklessCartoons responds:

And thank you so much for writing this review Putney! That is exactly the reaction or impact that I was hoping it would get. I appreciate it very much :)

[Scott Pilgrim Window Scene (ANIMATED)]

good work!
You got a lot of they physical comedy of the scene down nicely.
You also got a lot emotional expression out of them, and the animation was very smooth at the beginning, but I think you might have properly endorsed the fact that the perfect is the enemy of the good.
Thank you for making this.

boonsketi responds:

glad you enjoyed it!

[Treecko ah evolucionado]

Huh very cool!
I think maybe a very basic background of a few big rocks would help give alot of perspective and depth to this while not taking too much effort, but I really like how dynamic the motion is.
Also you could probably milk the evolution time little longer without too many details if you where trying to hit a longer run time .
also narratively it taking longer might make it seem more impactful, but I really like what you did here, and the amount oh emotion you rendered in such a short animation.
Thank you for making this.

DanielAnything responds:

Thank you very much !!! I really appreciate your words, I'll write everything down for the next one!
I am starting in the world of animation and the truth is that I enjoy it a lot as well as learning more things and risking doing things that I did not think I could do, thanks to this type of comments I am encouraged to experiment more and know what I can continue to do much more! Thank you !!